Merger law reform: Luke Wainscoat discusses how we should assess our merger control regime

Luke Wainscoat has published an editorial in the current issue of the Australian Journal of Competition and Consumer Law on the debate that Rod Sims started last year regarding the potential for merger law reform in Australia. The editorial is accessible here.

Luke examines how we can assess whether the current merger control regime is operating effectively. He says that we should not start by examining market power in Australia because this is very difficult to do at an economy wide level, and there are many potential causes of market power other than mergers.

Rather, Luke suggests that we focus on examining the effect of errors made by the merger control regime. Errors can occur when a merger that would have benefitted consumers is blocked, and when a merger that harms consumers is allowed. He finds that consumer welfare is maximised in the long run when the expected effects of errors and the operating costs of the regime are minimised.

With that in mind, Luke recommends that evidence should be collected on:

• the lost benefits to consumer welfare, if any, from mergers that were proposed but opposed by the ACCC (and did not go ahead) in the last ten years;
• the harms to consumer welfare, if any, from a selection of mergers that the ACCC opposed, but went ahead anyway in the last ten years; and
• the costs to operating the merger control regime, and how they may be changed by the ACCC’s proposals.

This evidence could be used to assess whether the merger control regime should be changed, and in particular whether it is too lenient.

Other news items you may find interesting

• Read more

  HoustonKemp advises on declaration in telecommunications markets

  Luke Wainscoat and Zoe Odgers have prepared a report for Pivotel…
• Read more

  Competition Tribunal denies authorisation for Telstra/TPG regional network deal

  The Competition Tribunal denied authorisation of a proposed mobile spectrum and network sharing agreement between Telstra and…
• Read more

  Analysing the materiality of GetSwift’s ASX announcements

  In 2017, startup ASX-listed technology company GetSwift and its directors made a series of announcements in relation to new…
• Read more

  The impact of COVID-19 on actual and forecast New South Wales population

  Released in mid-2022, the 2022 NSW Population Projections are the first population forecasts to be publicly released by the NSW…

View all